5 Easy Ways to Ruin a Margarita (2024)

We’ve all had bad Margaritas—and we’ve probably all been guilty of serving bad Margaritas. Let’s make a vow, here and now, to never do so again. Here, five easy mistakes you can make when shaking up a Margarita, and how to avoid them.

Problem: You’re Not Shaking Long Enough—or at All

A Margarita is not a co*cktail that you can build in the glass and stir with those tiny little sippy straws. It needs to be shaken—preferably with nice, large-format cubes—so that all the ingredients are fully incorporated, aerated, chilled and diluted. If you’re not shaking your Margarita, your co*cktail is going to be flat, limp and one dimensional.

Problem: You’re Using Too Much Sweetener

There are two classic ways of making a Margarita: with triple sec or with agave syrup (the Tommy’s Margarita). If you use both agave and triple sec in your Margarita—rather than one in place of the other—your co*cktail is going to be an overly sweet mess. Whatever you choose, be sure to keep your sweetener at or below three-quarters of an ounce; the two most important flavors in a Margarita are sour citrus and grassy tequila—not sugar.

Problem: You’re Using Sour Mix

If you didn’t already know, bottled sour mix is a blend of artificial lime juice, citric acid and corn syrup. In a Margarita, it makes the drink much sweeter than it needs to be and less acidic. If you really want your Margarita to shine, squeeze a lime with a hand press straight into your jigger. It will prevent any oxidation within the juice, and result in the freshest, liveliest Margarita possible.

Problem: You’re Using Bottom Shelf Tequilas

Believe it or not, a Margarita should taste like tequila—and good tequila at that. Our philosophy with making a Margarita (and any bartender worth their salt will agree) is that the tequila should be the star of the show, with the other ingredients boosting it up. Using lower quality tequilas will result in a crappy drink because you’re naturally going to want to hide the liquor’s taste with sweetners to make it more palatable. When you use a good tequila made from 100-percent agave, it gives the Margarita a vegetal pepperiness that perfectly contrasts the brightness of fresh lime.

Problem: You’re Rimming with Bad Salt

Yes, there is such a thing as “bad salt” for a Margarita rim. Stay away from salt with added iodine as well as curing salts that have crystals the size of small boulders. Instead, opt for a fine grain sea salt or any salt sold specifically for Margaritas (or make your own). If you’re more adventurous, you can even rim your co*cktail with sal de gusano, a piquant salt mixed with dehydrated and crushed larvae traditionally served with mezcals. While it sounds strange, it is the perfect accompaniment to the vegetal flavors inherent in good tequila (or mezcal), and it will definitely impress your pals.

5 Easy Ways to Ruin a Margarita (2024)

FAQs

How to weaken a strong margarita? ›

A margarita can be very powerful in regards to its capacity to inebriate you – or your guests – quickly. That's why it's best to fill the margarita glass two-thirds full with crushed ice and then pour in the margarita mixture described above in. As the ice melts, it will dilute the margarita.

What makes a margarita taste bad? ›

Another possibility is the person who batched the mix didn't add enough orange liqueur or maybe forgot it all together. Without some triple sec or classic curaçao the acidity of the lime juice can sometimes be too overwhelming.

How to jazz up a margarita? ›

How to Spice Up Your Margaritas
  1. Chili Paste. Adding hot sauce to the shaker is one of the easiest way to spice up a marg, but for a more concentrated heat, bartenders sometimes use chili paste. ...
  2. Infusions. ...
  3. Tinctures. ...
  4. Liqueurs. ...
  5. Garnishes.
Aug 30, 2023

How do you fix a drink that is too strong? ›

Too strong? Extra dilution is often all that's needed – try to do this by mixing on ice rather than just adding water as the chill factor is also important for making a co*cktail smooth.

How strong is 1 margarita? ›

They are sweet but strong, meeting the requirements of many drinkers. On average, a margarita is about 3 ounces of liquid. Of that, 2 to 2.5 ounces is alcohol, with a bit of lime juice/mixer and some water from melted ice. With 80-proof tequila and factoring in mixers and melting ice, margaritas have about 33% ABV.

How can I improve my margarita? ›

If you prefer a bit more flavor to your margarita or love a Paloma co*cktail, fruit juice is an easy way to give a bit more oomph and sweetness to a basic margarita, which just contains lime. Grapefruit juice perfectly complements the lime juice and tequila, while adding a good balance of sour, sweet, and tangy.

How unhealthy is a margarita? ›

Are margarita's healthy? With summer at our doorstep, margaritas are perfect for cooling down with friends while relaxing on the beach or by your backyard pool. Unfortunately, margarites often have many empty calories, which can lead to weight gain. Some margaritas contain up to 300 grams of sugar!

Should a margarita be shaken or stirred? ›

If the co*cktail ingredients are mostly, or entirely, spirits (such as in a Manhattan, Martini or Negroni), you should stir. If a co*cktail includes juice (such as in a Margarita, Daiquiri or Cosmo), you should shake.

How to take bitterness out of margaritas? ›

The first (and easiest) is just adding a pinch or using your salt shaker. A saline solution is commonly used by bartenders but might not be practical for a home bar. Another option is to use a salt rim, though that will only be pleasant for a select number of co*cktails. You could also just salt the source.

How to doctor up margarita mix? ›

Check out these ways to mix your margarita into a unique drink that'll take you to paradise.
  1. Sorbet. The Frozen Concoction Maker® perfectly shaves ice to create a refreshing frozen margarita. ...
  2. Cucumber. The key to using cucumber in your margaritas is two fold. ...
  3. Spicy. ...
  4. Mezcal. ...
  5. Moonshine. ...
  6. Key Lime. ...
  7. Pomegranate. ...
  8. Watermelon.

What neutralizes sour taste? ›

Sweetness: From sugar, honey, fruits or otherwise, sweetness will counteract bitter and sour flavours.

What is the secret ingredient in margaritas? ›

The secret to the perfect margarita, we discovered, is to skip Cointreau/orange liqueur altogether and replace it with freshly squeezed orange juice. The difference is remarkable.

Why do you put triple sec in margaritas? ›

Traditionally, orange has always been a classic pairing for any agave-based spirit, providing a sweeter complement without overpowering the notes of the agave. In Margaritas, the inclusion of triple sec provides a luscious, warm citric note that counterbalances the lime juice's high acidity.

How do you dress up a margarita? ›

The Garnishes.

You can include other citrus options too — orange slices or grapefruit wedges make a fun addition to a classic margarita. The second category of garnishes I rely on are non-citrus fruits. Consider adding sliced peaches,pomegranate seeds or some fresh berries to your set up.

How to dilute a strong margarita? ›

The way you achieve the right dilution is either stirring the co*cktail on ice long enough so that the stirring glass is almost too cold to hold, or shaking it until it's that cold. Voilà — you will have achieved optimal dilution. Strain it into the glass and it's ready to go. So counterintuitive!

How do you make alcohol taste less strong? ›

Adding ice to your drink can help to dilute the alcohol and make it less potent. This tends to make the taste of the alcohol less overwhelming, which makes it easier to drink.

How do you make tequila taste less strong? ›

Then, she adds a splash of mineral water, a tiny pinch of baking soda (“barely any”), and a little bit of salt (again, “barely any”). If you still taste the alcohol, she recommends adding a little more salt.

How do you make tequila go down easily? ›

Lick salt off your hand. The salt lessens the burn of the tequila. Immediately drink 1 1/2 ounces shot glass of tequila quickly. Immediately bite into and ​suck on lime or lemon wedge.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mr. See Jast

Last Updated:

Views: 5883

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mr. See Jast

Birthday: 1999-07-30

Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

Phone: +5023589614038

Job: Chief Executive

Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.