Nancy B’s Guide to the Perfect… Choux Pastry (2024)

Sweet and flaky, topped with chocolate, or oozing with cream, elegant choux pâtisseries are a doddle with Nancy B’s top five baking tips

The English translation of ‘pâtisserie’ is simply pastry – but it means so much more than that. These pastries are detailed, delicate and absolutely delicious in every way. I’ve have decided to concentrate on choux pastry – central to classics such as gâteau St Honoré, religieuse and choux à la crème, as well as our well-known favourites, éclairs and profiteroles.

Few people try their hand at choux pastry because they think it is the most difficult to master, but making choux pastry is actually fun!

Technique: ‘Shoot’ pastry

My grandmother taught me to make choux pastry – or, as she used to call it, ‘shoot’ pastry (you’ll understand why in a bit). Water, butter and salt are melted in a medium saucepan, and the liquid brought to a boil. Sifted flour is tipped onto a piece of greaseproof paper that has been folded in two. The fun then is to pour or ‘shoot’ the flour into the liquid and stir it with a wooden spoon until the mixture is smooth and leaves the side of the pan.

Next, the egg is added and blended well until the mixture is thick. As a guide, when the spoon or whisk is lifted out of the dough, a ‘V’ should be left hanging. In other words, the mixture is just a bit thicker than dropping consistency.

The dough is then piped onto a baking sheet and popped in a hot oven until risen and golden. Steam helps with the rising, so I find that spraying the baking sheet with water prior to piping on the dough helps to achieve a better choux.

Common problems: Failure to rise

There are two common problems encountered when making choux pastry. Firstly, if you add the eggs to your hot water and flour mixture before it has cooled, the eggs will cook in the paste and refuse to rise in the oven. I transfer my hot paste to a cool mixing bowl, stirring from time to time until it feels just warm to the touch. Then I add the eggs.

A second common problem is adding too much egg. Add the beaten egg a little at a time until the consistency described above is reached. Often less egg is required than stated in a recipe.

Style: The perfect éclair

All good pâtisseries have style, which means attention to detail. Your éclairs, for instance, should all be even in size. An easy way to do this is to take a five-inch (12.5cm) scraper, dip the long edge in flour, then make horizontal marks on the baking sheet, which serve as a guide when piping the choux.

See Also
FAQ

I also find that using a star-shaped piping nozzle results in a finer shaped éclair. The ridges disappear during baking and the finished choux is perfectly rounded. Decoration is your final opportunity to make your bakes beautiful – chocolate, of course, being a firm favourite for both éclairs and profiteroles.

Ingredient: Fruit powder

The perfect éclair or profiterole should be crisp on the outside, with a delicious, smooth filling on the inside. My favourite ingredient for filling a baked choux is crème pâtisserie.

If fresh fruit puree is used, the amount of fruit necessary to add flavour will result in the cream being too wet – making the choux soggy. However, a dry concentrated fruit powder mixed in with the cream will not affect the consistency at all.

Freeze-dried fruit powders are available online – do try the passion fruit, it is absolutely delicious and my favourite! 

Inspiration: Bottom-up éclairs

Éclairs are often made by slicing them in half and adding a delicious, creamy filling. This is fine and utterly delicious, but try making them look ‘top end’ by filling them from the base. This is quite simple to do: with a metal piping nozzle make three equally spaced holes in the base of the éclair – wobbling and twisting it to make sure you have created space for the filling.

Then use your weighing scales to work out the amount of filling you need to pipe into each of the three holes. I usually find that about 60g of filling for each éclair is perfect. Wipe off any surplus cream from the underside then decorate your éclair on the presentation side.

Your friends and family will wonder how you managed to get the cream into such a perfect-looking bake!

@nancybbakes wonGreat British Bake Off 2014. Since then she’s travelled from Cornwall to The Shetland Isles, baking and entertaining fans.

Learn more about her food and her travels on her blog.

Nancy B’s Guide to the Perfect… Choux Pastry (2024)

FAQs

What are the mistakes when making choux pastry? ›

Potential reasons for each fault include insufficient cooling, eggs added too quickly, not beating the mixture enough, incorrect baking temperature or time, insufficient baking, and allowing the liquid to cool too much before adding flour.

What is the most important ingredient in choux pastry? ›

The essential ingredients are butter, water, flour and eggs. Instead of a raising agent, choux pastry employs its high moisture content to create steam, as the water in the dough evaporates when baked, puffing the pastry.

What is the best flour for choux pastry? ›

I've written the recipe using plain (all-purpose) flour as it's the most accessible flour globally and one that most will have in their pantry. That said, choux pastry can also be made with bread or cake flour. Bread flour has a higher protein and gluten content, resulting in a sturdier pastry shell.

What is the best consistency for choux? ›

Pour in the final addition of beaten eggs very slowly. Stop adding when the choux pastry has reached the desired texture: shiny, thick, and smooth with a pipeable consistency. I usually leave a few teaspoons of beaten egg behind, which can be used with the egg wash.

What is the best piping tip for choux pastry? ›

When piping choux pastry into eclairs, using a French star nozzle (as pictured here) will reduce the amount of cracking in the pastry as well as help to retain a neater, more consistent eclair shape as it bakes. If you don't have a French star nozzle, an open star nozzle is the next best option.

How do you keep choux pastry crispy? ›

Shelf-life & Refeshing your Choux

You can keep the Choux in an airtight container for up to 3 days. They will feel soggy when you take them out so it's important to put them in a 175°C oven for about 5 minutes. That will dry and crisp them back up. ..But I suggest to use,the same day you make them, so much better.

Is milk better than water for choux pastry? ›

The Liquid: You can use water or milk, or a combination of the two. Water allows you to bake either hotter or longer (or both) without as much risk of the choux over-browning, while milk, thanks to its extra proteins and sugars, leads to a more rapidly browned crust.

What 3 things do you look for to tell if your choux pastry is ready? ›

Your dough should be shiny and smooth.

You will know it's ready when the pastry has a consistency that slowly closes in on itself once the spoon has passed through. Your choux ball is ready when you have a skin at the bottom of the pan, which takes about 2-3 minutes on medium heat.

What is the formula for choux pastry? ›

Typical choux pastry formula includes:2,3

Bring the milk, water, sugar, salt and butter to a boil, stir to combine. Remove from heat source, add the flour and continue stirring. Heat the mix again while stirring till the mixture becomes a cohesive mass and clears the side of the pot.

What are the qualities of a good choux pastry? ›

The choux buns should be golden brown and, what pastry chefs call, 'dry' on the inside. This effectively means the inside should feel moist but no moisture is to be seen. If they sink after baking this means there was still too much moisture inside and you will need a slightly longer baking time.

What temperature should choux pastry be cooked at? ›

Bake in the 480°F (250°C) preheated oven, then drop the oven temperature to 350°F (180°C) right away. Bake for 25 minutes (do not open the oven in the meantime!) or a little bit longer if needed, until the choux become golden in color.

Is butter or margarine better for choux pastry? ›

The most used fat is butter, but choux pastry can be made also with oil, margarine or lard. The higher is the content of fat, the more the cream puff will be crumbly and rounded with a smooth surface. Less is the fat (compared to the flour), lighter the cream puff will be (with an irregular and cracked surface).

What does pâte à choux mean? ›

noun. (ˌ)pä-tä-ˈshü : a very light dough used to make pastries : choux pastry. … the French pastry dough pate a choux, which is also responsible for cream puffs and eclairs.

Why does my choux pastry taste eggy? ›

Pâte à Choux is too Eggy

Also, if the puffs do not bake long enough, then they may taste slightly eggy because the insides haven't cooked long enough. We want the pastries to be crisp on the outside and dry on the inside. Solutions: Don't use too many eggs and bake long enough to dry them out.

Is choux pastry better with water or milk? ›

In many instances you can use one or the other in the same choux recipe without issue, though it can be useful to take advantage of a milk-based choux's enhanced browning when baking smaller pastries like chouquettes and éclairs, allowing you to achieve a good level of color development without risk of over-baking the ...

How do you keep choux crispy? ›

Shelf-life & Refeshing your Choux

You can keep the Choux in an airtight container for up to 3 days. They will feel soggy when you take them out so it's important to put them in a 175°C oven for about 5 minutes. That will dry and crisp them back up. ..But I suggest to use,the same day you make them, so much better.

What is the texture of a successful choux pastry? ›

The choux buns should be golden brown and, what pastry chefs call, 'dry' on the inside. This effectively means the inside should feel moist but no moisture is to be seen. If they sink after baking this means there was still too much moisture inside and you will need a slightly longer baking time.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Roderick King

Last Updated:

Views: 6010

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Roderick King

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: 3782 Madge Knoll, East Dudley, MA 63913

Phone: +2521695290067

Job: Customer Sales Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Embroidery, Parkour, Kitesurfing, Rock climbing, Sand art, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Roderick King, I am a cute, splendid, excited, perfect, gentle, funny, vivacious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.